| 2018-19 |
Bob Burchard |
15-16 |
10-12 |
Quarterfinals - L, Missouri Baptist 52-51 |
- |
| 2017-18 |
Bob Burchard |
27-5 |
19-3 |
Quarterfinals - L, Lyon 65-61 |
Round 1 - L, Campbellsville 75-66 |
| 2016-17 |
Bob Burchard |
27-6 |
19-4 |
Quarterfinals - L, Missouri Baptist 78-73 |
Round 1 - W, Lewis-Clark State 71-59
Round of 16 - L, Pikeville 56-51 |
| 2015-16 |
Bob Burchard |
29-6 |
18-4 |
Quarterfinals - W, Harris-Stowe 87-81
Semifinals - W, Park 86-81
Finals - W, William Woods 77-74 |
Round 1 - W, LSU-Shreveport 94-68
Round of 16 - L, William Penn 86-68 |
| 2014-15 |
Bob Burchard |
26-7 |
18-4 |
Quarterfinals - W, Benedictine at Springfield 82-43
Semifinals - L, Lindenwood-Belleville 71-69 |
Round 1 - L, Our Lady of the Lake 74-68 |
| 2013-14 |
Bob Burchard |
32-3 |
19-1 |
Quarterfinals - W, William Woods 79-65
Semifinals - W, Park 66-65
Finals - W, Freed-Hardeman 86-78 |
Round 1 - W, Belhaven 81-57
Round of 16 - L, MidAmerica Nazarene 80-75 |
| 2012-13 |
Bob Burchard |
35-1 |
16-0 |
Quarterfinals - W, HLGU 67-52
Semifinals - W, Williams Baptist 97-56
Finals - W, Park 77-63 |
Round 1 - W, Oklahoma City 68-37
Round of 16 - W, Hope International 66-64
Quarterfinals - L, LSU-Shreveport 79-78 |
| 2011-12 |
Bob Burchard |
27-7 |
11-1 |
Semifinals - W, Park 78-64
Finals - W, HLGU 80-46 |
Round 1 - W, Montana State-Northern 58-52
Round of 16 - L, Oklahoma Baptist 69-57 |
| 2010-11 |
Bob Burchard |
26-6 |
12-2 |
Quarterfinals - W, HLGU 63-45
Semifinals - L, Park 60-56 |
Round 1 - L, Lee Univ. 69-67 |
| 2009-10 |
Bob Burchard |
13-19 |
6-7 |
Quarterfinals - W, HLGU 58-53
Semifinals - L, McKendree 72-44 |
- |
| 2008-09 |
Bob Burchard |
30-8 |
11-4 |
Quarterfinals - W, Williams Baptist 89-88
Semifinals - W, UIS 84-79
Finals - W, McKendree 65-54 |
Round 1 - W, Lee Univ. 72-69
Round of 16 - W, Union 84-64
Quarterfinals - W, Westminster 50-47
Semifinals - W, MidAmerica Nazarene 60-56
Championship - L, Rocky Mountain 77-61 |
| 2007-08 |
Bob Burchard |
25-9 |
11-3 |
Quarterfinals - W, Missouri Baptist 71-54
Semifinals - W, UIS 76-69
Finals - L, McKendree 75-71 |
Round 1 - L, Azusa Pacific 61-47 |
| 2006-07 |
Bob Burchard |
16-16 |
7-5 |
Quarterfinals - W, Williams Baptist 81-73
Semifinals - L, McKendree 84-75 |
- |
| 2005-06 |
Bob Burchard |
24-9 |
9-3 |
Quarterfinals - W, Williams Baptist 90-46
Semifinals - L, McKendree 83-72 |
Round 1 - L, Oklahoma City 91-64 |
| 2004-05 |
Bob Burchard |
21-14 |
9-3 |
Quarterfinals - W, Harris-Stowe 81-65
Semifinals - L, McKendree 63-62 |
Round 1 - L, Mountain State (W. Va.) 77-50 |
| 2003-04 |
Bob Burchard |
32-4 |
10-2 |
Quarterfinals - W, Harris-Stowe 119-45
Semifinals - W, McKendree 63-43
Finals - W, Missouri Baptist 80-65 |
Round 1 - L, Oklahoma City 81-48 |
| 2002-03 |
Bob Burchard |
25-9 |
7-3 |
Quarterfinals - W, Harris-Stowe 91-61
Semifinals - W, Missouri Baptist 81-65
Finals - L, McKendree 81-59 |
Round 1 - L, Wayland Baptist 72-68 |
| 2001-02 |
Bob Burchard |
28-8 |
6-4 |
Semifinals - W, Missouri Baptist 80-66
Finals - L, McKendree 66-56 |
Round 1 - L, Barat College (IL) 93-86 |
| 2000-01 |
Bob Burchard |
29-4 |
9-0 |
Semifinals - W, HLGU 69-55
Finals - W, McKendree 73-70 |
Round 1 - W, Union (TN) 75-66
Round of 16 - L, Spring Hill 69-43 |
| 1999-00 |
Bob Burchard |
26-8 |
8-2 |
Semifinals - W, Missouri Baptist 84-68
Finals - W, McKendree 72-61 |
Round 1 - L, Olivet Nazarene 62-59 |
| 1998-99 |
Bob Burchard |
22-7 |
7-3 |
Semifinals - W, HLGU 67-60
Finals - W, Missouri Baptist 73-59 |
Round 1 - W, Birmingham-Southern (AL) 62-56
Round of 16 - L, Concordia 58-53 |
| 1997-98 |
Bob Burchard |
16-17 |
3-7 |
Quarterfinals - W, Missouri Baptist 99-88
Semifinals - L, Park 91-79 |
- |
| 1996-97 |
Bob Burchard |
27-8 |
7-3 |
Semifinals - W, Park 65-63
Finals - W, McKendree 62-61 |
Round 1 - L, Azusa Pacific 61-55 |
| 1995-96 |
Bob Burchard |
27-8 |
9-3 |
W, HLGU 70-64
L, Park 65-63 |
Round 1 - L, Cumberland 65-58 |
| 1994-95 |
Bob Burchard |
29-6 |
13-1 |
W, Lindenwood 99-80
L, Iowa Wesleyan 122-113 |
Round 1 - L, Fresno Pacific 81-56 |
| 1993-94 |
Bob Burchard |
24-8 |
9-4 |
L, Park 63-62 |
- |
| 1992-93 |
Bob Burchard |
- |
- |
- |
District 16 Quarterfinals - W, Missouri Baptist 83-75
District 16 Semifinals - W, Rockhurst 97-89
District 16 Finals - L, Drury 78-64 |
| 1991-92 |
Bob Burchard |
23-13 |
- |
W, Lindenwood 83-58
L, Missouri Baptist 75-68 |
District 16 Quarterfinals - W, Rockhurst 90-64
District 16 Semifinals - L, Drury 78-64 |
| 1990-91 |
Bob Burchard |
26-8 |
- |
L, Park 108-90 |
District 16 Quarterfinals - W, Missouri Valley 115-106
District 16 Semifinals - W, College of the Ozarks 69-68
District 16 Finals - L, Park 108-90 |
| 1989-90 |
Bob Burchard |
30-8 |
- |
W, Lindenwood 97-60
L, Missouri Baptist 101-89 |
District 16 - W, Tarkio 90-85
District 16 - W, Central Methodist 89-88
District 16 - W, Drury 83-80
National Tournament - W, Malone 93-88
National Tournament - L, Oral Roberts 106-86 |
| 1988-89 |
Bob Burchard |
18-12 |
- |
- |
- |
